There's only one thing Bachelor Nation wants to know right now. No, it's not who Peter Weber picked as his finalist (seriously, we still don't know (open in new tab). Rather, fans want answers about that itty-bitty finger tattoo that Weber had on his one-on-one date with Sydney Hightower. (Opens in new tab) As the two whispered sweet nothings to each other, Weber called her the best kisser in the group, and he reached out to caress Hightower's neck, the fans screamed in unison: "Wait, does Peter have a tattoo I don't know about? The answer is yes. It's the number 12.

As first discovered by Cosmopolitan (opens in new tab), there is actually an old Us Weekly (opens in new tab) article (opens in new tab) in which Weber mentions the tattoo: "My brother and I were in awe when our beloved Seattle Seahawks Super Bowl win, we got matching tattoos of our number 12.

This was in 2014, which means he had had the tattoo for six years. And interestingly, no one noticed until this moment.

See the tattoo that caused all this drama up close:

Also, if you want to see the tattoo in motion, you can find it around 2 minutes and 10 seconds into this video:

Now the real question: is it his only tattoo?

Seriously, you would have thought that The Bachelor would have made his season ending a tattoo.

For more stories like this, including celebrity news, beauty and fashion advice, savvy political commentary, fascinating features, and more, sign up for the Marie Claire newsletter.

Click here to subscribe (opens in new tab)